Haven't critiqued anything in a while, and then I saw this. So naturally, I thought, why not offer a critique? I comment myself for my genius.
Okay not really. Anyways, I'll just get started with the critique. ;
VISION Great! Everything is nice in this! The animation is smooth, the expressions are nice, your meaning is very well conveyed. I love how the laptop sort of 'bounces' when he's typing. I can't find anything wrong with the vision, so great job! I'll give you a 4.5/5 for vision.
ORIGINALITY This is really original! I don't think I've actually seen any other deviation like this before! Maybe I just don't browse enough, but this definitely isn't an overdone concept, so great job for being original! Whoo! I'll give you a 4.5/5 for originality.
TECHNIQUE The animation is really smooth, the explosions are flawless. The shading is great, everything fits perfectly. I guess you could add come lighting from the laptop. I can't really tell if it the light blue blob below the emote's eyes is light from the laptop, or if it's part of the shading itself. I guess that's the only thing that bothers me, everything else is great. I'll give you a 4/5 for technique.
IMPACT I think this is the only category where I can point out a few somewhat solid drawbacks. First off, if it weren't for the words, I would think that the emote's computer froze. It's really not clear that it's online advertising that caused the... explosions. And speaking of explosions, I can understand why the laptop exploded, but the emote? That was a bit weird. Sure, it acts as a nice transition, but I think it's a bit unnecessary and kind of weird. Even though it was animated perfectly. Here's a good thing: It's actually great you used a gray background for the stamp, because the emotes different color emphasizes it and makes it the main focus of the picture, not the background, not the letters. So good job on that! I'll give you a 3.5/5 for impact.
Great great great job! The only reason I docked a few points on some of the categories was because I don't like giving (near) perfect scores, it makes me feel like I didn't help. So yeah! I think you deserve a bit higher, but hopefully my critique helped!
Your emotes and stamps are always amazing. (400 words! )
Ok I'm trying to be friendly on this. First of all, this is a fantastic animation on the stamp. When that blue guy gets too pissed and it goes BOOM! that's an epic moment on this stamp. Plus, this is a great stamp for people who hates ads on the internet. Anyway, it would be better if that blue guy was checking a website and a ad appears and then gets very pissed. You should at least try making the background more detailed than this one. It would look fantastic! But altogether,I love every piece of this stamp!
ugh I agree I remember I was looking at minecraft videos on youtube and then it says "Choose your AD!" and I x it out but it chooses a 10 minute one "interviewing" (talking) pets! now don't get me wrong I love animals and all but I thought it was annoying. but of course after 5 minutes u got to skip! I was still annoyed at youtube for making me watch an ad. then after the video I saw a comment that said 'I want to see MINECRAFT videos not F***ing ads!" and I clicked
dA found my weakness a cat that looks disappointed and it says "this little cat wants to see your art. don't disappoint her!" ten I click and Idk how to do it! damn you dA! oh its reading my mind it just showed one that says "lickable ad space for lickable art." its reading my mind ahhh!
Oh God this! There's a site I watch dubbed anime on that not only has a talking ad on the homepage, but it spawns a popup every time I open a new page on the site. Amen for adblock!
I was on youtube and I was watching a video, and suddenly I heard some voice that I knew was not coming from the video, and it was really anoying... I figured out that it was an advertisment... OH MY STARCLAN IT IS SO ANOYING.
Okay not really. Anyways, I'll just get started with the critique.
VISION
Great! Everything is nice in this! The animation is smooth, the expressions are nice, your meaning is very well conveyed. I love how the laptop sort of 'bounces' when he's typing. I can't find anything wrong with the vision, so great job!
I'll give you a 4.5/5 for vision.
ORIGINALITY
This is really original! I don't think I've actually seen any other deviation like this before! Maybe I just don't browse enough, but this definitely isn't an overdone concept, so great job for being original! Whoo!
I'll give you a 4.5/5 for originality.
TECHNIQUE
The animation is really smooth, the explosions are flawless. The shading is great, everything fits perfectly. I guess you could add come lighting from the laptop. I can't really tell if it the light blue blob below the emote's eyes is light from the laptop, or if it's part of the shading itself. I guess that's the only thing that bothers me, everything else is great.
I'll give you a 4/5 for technique.
IMPACT
I think this is the only category where I can point out a few somewhat solid drawbacks. First off, if it weren't for the words, I would think that the emote's computer froze. It's really not clear that it's online advertising that caused the... explosions.
And speaking of explosions, I can understand why the laptop exploded, but the emote?
Here's a good thing: It's actually great you used a gray background for the stamp, because the emotes different color emphasizes it and makes it the main focus of the picture, not the background, not the letters.
So good job on that!
I'll give you a 3.5/5 for impact.
Great great great job! The only reason I docked a few points on some of the categories was because I don't like giving (near) perfect scores, it makes me feel like I didn't help.
Your emotes and stamps are always amazing.
(400 words!
First of all, this is a fantastic animation on the stamp. When that blue guy gets too pissed and it goes BOOM! that's an epic moment on this stamp. Plus, this is a great stamp for people who hates ads on the internet. Anyway, it would be better if that blue guy was checking a website and a ad appears and then gets very pissed. You should at least try making the background more detailed than this one. It would look fantastic!
Made by the not amazing *StarLight134!
The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork
Please sign up or login to post a critique.